Ethical Considerations Follow-Up Informed Consent Living Donor Research Living Kidney Donor Organ Markets

More Bad News For Iranian Kidney Donors – er – Sellers

From Transplant Proceedings:


With assistance of the Iranian Kidney Foundation, we accessed the contact information of living donors through the years 2001–2012. We tried to contact donors who have donated at least 2 years before the survey. We interviewed these donors according to a questionnaire that was approved by the ethics committee of the research deputy of Tehran University of Medical Sciences. The collected data were analyzed using the SPSS software version 20.


The contact data of 388 donors were available but we were able to contact only 60 donors. We found that 40% of donors had been informed about the risks and benefits of donation. Also, 11% of donors had not had a full physical examination and in 5% even blood pressure was not measured before donation by the transplantation team. The donors reported that 34% of them had not been educated on how they should follow up their health status and 50% of the donors did not have any follow-up after donation.


The most understated conclusion in the history of conclusions:


In the Iranian model of transplantation the donors are the neglected victims of renal transplantation and this model should be revised immediately, concerning both the medical and ethical issues.


Khatami, M., Nikravan, N., & Alimohammadi, F. (2015). Quality and Quantity of Health Evaluation and the Follow-up of Iranian Living Donors Transplantation Proceedings, 47 (4), 1092-1095 DOI: 10.1016/j.transproceed.2014.11.059

Add Your Thoughts